All publications
Other

All the Same?

Three articles on the role, mechanism and origins of differentiation in political perceptions

Felix Grünewald

Ph.D. dissertation, University of Hamburg

Abstract

“They are all the same” is a ubiquitous statement in political discussions, be it a statement about supposed convergence of mainstream parties or consistency of attitudes and traits of partisan out-groups. Across three papers, I explore differentiation, the perception of differences between people and groups, as a relevant dimension of politics. I build on research from political science and psychology to study how group identities and party communication shape this perception, and how a lack of differentiation is connected to negative feelings towards political opponents. The first article introduces the concept of out-group homogeneity to the study of left-right party camps. Using comparative CSES data and German panel data, I show that the opposite camp is perceived as more homogeneous than one’s own and that this perception is connected to stronger dislike and a lower likelihood of voting for the other camp. The second article explores how impressions of one out-group member affect the evaluation of others. An online survey experiment in the United States shows that negative impressions are transferred to distinct out-party members. Finally, the third article shifts the focus to party communication. Using a pledge-based measure of vagueness in manifestos linked to CSES survey data, I show that more vague communication is associated with parties being perceived closer to each other and to the political center. Together, the three papers show that differentiation matters for how citizens perceive political opponents, process inter-group contact and distinguish electoral alternatives. I conclude that democratic relations may benefit from giving more attention to the differences that persist within and between political groups.